Jamison vs. Somers

The District 1 (Perry) seat on the NACS School Board is currently held by Kent Somers but his term is up this year. Read some of the reasons why Kent needs to be replaced.

Erica Jamison filed to run against Kent Somers this year and after reviewing her website at www.ericajamison.com we decided to fully support her campaign.

Chaffee vs. Dohl

The District 2 (Eel River) seat on the NACS School Board is currently held by Steve Bartkus. Steve did not file to run this year but two new candidates filed to run for election for that seat. They are Liz Chaffee and Mary Kate Dohl. We sent questions to both of these candidates to learn more about them. In the blue box is a copy of the exact email we sent to both candidates. Below the box you will find their responses to each question. We thank them both for answering our questions. After reviewing their responses we have decided to support Mary Kate Dohl for the District 2 seat.

We are a non-partisan Political Action Committee that was formed in 2022. Our group is made up of parents, students, alumni, teachers, and other past and present NACS staff with a variety of backgrounds and opinions. One thing we all agree on is that we want to continue the excellence of our school district and keep extremism out of our schools. We would love to hear your answers to some questions so we can learn more about you as a candidate for NACS School Board. 

  1. Why did you decide to run?

  2. What do you think are the most pressing issues NACS faces? 

  3. What is the role of a school board member and what makes a good school board member?

  4. Have you attended any NACS school board meetings recently? If so, what are your thoughts on how they were conducted? 

  5. Do you have a personal relationship with any current school board members?

  6. Do you support the Indiana’s Choice Scholarship Program and diverting referendum money to vouchers?

  7. Are you familiar with Moms for Liberty and do you support them? 

  8. Are you familiar with Purple for Parents? Do you plan to seek their endorsement?

  9. Is there anything else you would like us to know about you? 

Thank you in advance for answering these questions! - Committee to Support Public Education in Northwest Allen County

Liz Chaffee’s responses

  • I was approached by several people asking me to run. I will admit I laughed at the idea. Then my husband came home as he was approached to talk to me about it.  After more discussion and requests I thought more seriously about it and talked with my husband to finally decide that it would be a good choice. It has been over 20 years since there was a retired NACS teacher on the board. Ultimately, I realized that I feel there is a current need to have someone on the board that can listen and work with teachers, staff, students, parents, administrators, & other board members to help make NACS the best it can be for all. I feel that I am the person to do this.

  • NACS has many issues to deal with. I will admit that I have not followed closely, the past year, with all the issues as I was focusing on my classroom kids and their progress as I finished my last year of teaching.  I am aware of some issues as they have been discussed in the monthly roundtable I attended with Mr. Barker, Dr. Toller, & other admin as a NACEA building rep. If I am on the board, I am ready to listen and research each issue before forming an opinion.

  • I feel every NACS school board member should be in that position because they want to make our school district better than it already is. Their role should be to listen, research, and discuss each issue that arises as well as look ahead to make changes as needed to possibly head off issues that could arise as well as to make NACS move in a forward motion to get better each day. During my 26 years of employment with NACS I have observed many different board members. Each have had different personal and political views. I feel a good board member works for what is best for all of NACS and not what is driven by their own personal & political views. We each have our own personal opinions and goals but not 1 person can make decisions alone. It is always important to listen to others experiences and opinions then research and discuss that is best for everyone at NACS. 

  • I was just at the last meeting on Monday, June 24th. After the retirement reception and awards all others left but I stayed to listen to the meeting. I feel they were very professional and informative to the few that attended.  I like that the meetings are streamed so those at home can watch as well as minutes posted so all can be informed.  I will admit I did not go out to grab the paperwork before the meeting started, so I was there just to listen. When I left, I did grab the minutes as well as see the sign in sheet for the audience to ask to speak during the allotted time. It felt like it was run efficiently as well as with the online streaming option and minutes being posted NACS is following through with their goal to be transparent in what they are doing and discussing.

  • I have met each of the current school board members. During my 26 years working for NACS, 21 years being involved in the Allen County 4 H program, years of travel soccer with my boys, being the backstage mom for CHS show choir, girl scout leader... I have formed relationships with many people. I was honored to be the kindergarten teacher for Will Barkus who is the son of current board member Steve Bartkus.  I was also able to be apart their families' adventures while we were all involved with the Allen County 4 H program. I attended the same High School as Darren Voigt. He graduated the year behind me though. He & I were also on the same committee of teachers, parents, administrators, and staff during the last redistricting.

  • I have never personally used the Indiana's Choice Scholarship Program (referendum) as we moved in the NACS district so our kids could attend NACS schools.  I understand that not all kids are the same and some families pursue other schools for the choices they need for each child to be as successful as they can be. I am not sure I understand the referendum program completely.  I need to research this whole process more to better understand it.  I still struggle to understand why NACS is one of the lowest in quantity of money received per child to start with. I do know that they have now added a second count day and I do appreciate that change. 

  • I will admit I had no idea what Moms for Liberty is, and I had to look it up to discover their goals and plans. They seem to be a national group. I respect the desire of each parent to do what is best for their child(ren). I have had to do this for my own children as they progressed through their education at NACS. At this time, I feel I do not have enough knowledge of what the goal of this group is and I want to stay focused on what I can do as a school board member to better anything I can for NACS as a whole.

  • I was not aware what Purple for Parents was until I looked it up. I am not going out to look for endorsements. I appreciate anyone who wants to support me, but I am not going out and seeking support. I am who I am. I feel I am the right choice to join the NACS school Board. I believe my experiences as a NACS teacher would be a benefit to the NACS school board to give a different perspective and outlook of how to look at different situations.

  • I would greatly appreciate support from anyone who believes I will be the best choice to work on the NACS school board. I believe that I can bring beneficial input from my many teaching experiences to the board.  I am known to be honest in my responses and repeatedly tell anyone to not ask me a question unless you want to hear my honest answer. I am transparent of my beliefs and am open to talk with anyone who wants to learn more about why I want to be on the NACS school board.

Mary Kate Dohl’s responses

  • I have long-held a passion for public service.  In 2022 I was elected to serve on the Eel River Township Board, and have found that our work helping residents in crisis to be incredibly rewarding.  My oldest daughter started at Huntertown in 2016, and since then I have volunteered as much as possible to serve as a field trip chaperone, book fair cashier, Boomerang Backpack stuffer and PTO volunteer/office, among others.  I love being in the schools, the culture of our public schools is unmatched in its joy and tenderness.  Next year I will have a student in high school, one in middle school, and my youngest in elementary school.  I love this community and can bring the voice of the parent experience to the school board, as a parent of a student athlete, a parent of a student with an IEP, and a parent of students facing growing threats from social media and the toxicity of the internet.  I truly believe that I am the best person to serve our students with a focus on safety, transparency, and opportunity.  I want to ensure our school board focuses on real dangers with practical solutions, not get distracted by culture war issues that divert resources from our deserving kids.  I am committed to making sure every student feels welcomed and valued within our schools.

    In 2007 I graduate from George Mason University with a Master's Degree in Environmental and Public Policy, and I have used what I learned there every day since.  The central tenet of policy-making is that whatever you want people to do, make it easy to do the right thing (not unlike parenting!).  On the NACS School Board, that would look like investing and supporting upgrades to technology that makes it easier for parents to communicate with teachers and administrators, and easier for students to enroll in expanded opportunities. I would love to see our district policies digitized so that it's easy to search and find specific language (currently it is nearly impossible to find what you're looking for). It might look like a commitment to transparency when I respond to every email or phone call from a concerned parent, so we continue to build trust across the district.

  • Growth is absolutely our most pressing issue in Northwest Allen County Schools.  We see the new buildings going up and parents are quick to understand why we need a new middle school, a ninth elementary, and within ten years likely a new high school or stand-alone vocational school.  It is much harder to explain to voters that we also need to grow our staff beyond teachers and resource aides.  Our administrative staff is severely overworked, our student census has more than doubled in 25 years but in many cases we still have a single employee doing the job that should really be split into two or three people.  Often voters see the requests for more staff in admin as 'bloat', but in our case we are so anemic that we face a crisis of attrition.  While we can't promise an increase in salaries without more state dollars or a potential referendum like SACS, we can reduce the workload of our staff by distributing the tasks more appropriately as we grow our team.  In some cases, we have teachers or administrators voluntarily doing the jobs that our neighboring districts have dedicated personnel for, and investing in our people is long overdue.

    While adding personnel to central office isn't as 'sexy' as a new building, it is something that certainly trickles down to parents and students.

  • The most successful school board members understand that they represent every member of our district, not just the people who voted for them and not just the ones they agree with.  However, the role of a school board member is governance, not management.  School board members are non-partisan and must remain removed from the day-to-day decisions that are the responsibility of the superintendent and the NACS admin staff.  Our most important role is the hiring and support of the superintendent, including removing him/her if we lose confidence.  Additionally, school board members must adhere to strict confidentiality to protect the rights of our students and staff, and maintain the trust of the voters.  While it is good and necessary for school board members to disagree publicly, once a decision is made board members must unify around the decision and act as a team when facing the public.

  • I have attended every school board meeting this academic year (either in-person or virtually), and spoke at the January 8th board meeting to share my thoughts on the communication failures after a lockdown at Carroll Middle School.  I've also attended several work sessions and have found the board to be very thoughtful and have appreciated questions from Ms. Hathaway and Ms. Schlatter; both are successful at bringing the discussion back to what is most important, the students.  The admin team continues to be impressive in their transparency about the challenges and needs of a growing district.  

    I have had some concerns with two specific issues, 1) the desire of Mr. Vogt to entertain a change to the make-up of the board, and 2) the request from Mr. Barkus and Mr. Somers to have the admin team quantify how many students are impacted by each item requested in the ten-year plan presented on June 20th.  The first issue would by design be a political one, any change to how constituents are represented has significant repercussions, particularly in my district of Eel River.  I would not support any changes at this time, and haven't heard a persuasive argument for why they would be needed.  The second issue highlights a big disconnect between members of the board who have students in the district and those who don't.  The ten-year plan would add several administrative staff, as well as extension teachers like PEAK and Instructional Assistants.  These are things districts like ours have done, and done years ago, and also aligns with what I have personally heard from staff in our schools.  Setting aside that quantifying the number of students affected is a resource-intensive and imperfect task, it also worries me when we only value programs or people based on the size of the program.  In my years as a PTO volunteer and officer, when a new program was introduced, I always asked, "who are we leaving out?"  As Ms. Schlatter pointed out during the work session, we have other programs like theatre or show choir that are often overshadowed by athletics or academics, but are no less valuable.  Any desire to prioritize spending should use program size as only one metric of value.

  • I do not have any close personal relationships with current school board members, though I have met with Liz Hathaway a few times and with Kristi Schlatter once to discuss the challenges we face as a district and our shared interest in making NACS the best place to work for teachers, and the best place to learn for our students.

  • No.  While public school vouchers on their merits may be beneficial to some students and their families, Indiana's school choice program has been disastrous for public education.  Our nation's great promise is a free education to all students, public schools turn no one away, regardless of need or accommodation, we welcome all.  Our public schools are also required to meet state and federal standards for facility access, teacher qualifications/certifications, and after-school programs, to name a few.  Charter schools have no such minimums nor do they have any rigorous accountability for financial management of taxpayer dollars.  So far, under successive GOP administrations in the state, charter schools have taken state dollars and either disappeared after failing to successfully educate some of our most vulnerable students, or use the Choice Scholarship as a coupon for wealthy families to get a discount on tuition.  Unless the program is overhauled to meet parity with public school regulations, I cannot support any motion to divert referendum money to vouchers.

  • I am familiar with M4L and do not support them in any shape or form.  The chapter in NACS is small, but vocal, and is toxic to our community.  As a long-time volunteer, specifically at the Scholastic Book Fair, I have noted that members of this fringe group never appear in the schools where they could clearly see that their claims are ridiculous.

  • I am also familiar with P4P and have found their worldview to be shocking and appalling.  I would reject any endorsement.

  • As a kid, I was a ballet dancer and found a chosen family amongst my peers and incredible teachers, nearly all of which I still have in my life today.  As a young mom, I joined a MOPS program at Sonrise Christian Preschool that changed my life; my best friends today were young moms I met there when we were all so desperate for adult conversation.  Both of those experiences taught me that regardless of our politics, religion, or race, we are all just searching for community.  I think the reason I feel called to public service on the School Board, is because I recognize that for most of our families, our schools are the heart of the community we belong to.  Our schools are where our kids find their people, whether its football or chess club or theatre or cheer.  Our teachers do great work in the classroom with reading, writing, and math, but schools are so much more than that.  Schools are where we feed hungry kids.  It's where we keep kids safe who may be scared to go home.  Its where we partner with other kid-focused organizations to teach t-ball or hear a symphony play, for some it may the first and last time they get to play an instrument or see an axolotl in a generous teacher's classroom.  

    I heard someone say recently that asking for help is "a prayer to a friend". And for me, that's what our public schools are for our families.  When a kiddo needs extra help reading, or a middle-school friend group struggles with bullying, even when families face a medical crisis, our people step-up, no matter how big or small, to make sure those kids know we love them and will be there.  That's what public education is for me, the soundtrack to our kids lives, where the melody is a beating heart so they never feel alone. I'm running for school board because I want to keep our focus on these incredible students and the people who love them.

The Journal Gazette also asked all four candidates to answer some questions. Liz Chaffee declined to answer their questions but the other three candidates did. You can read all of their answers at: https://www.journalgazette.net/elections/4-seek-two-northwest-allen-county-schools-board-seats/article.